Football Hayes & Cannon

The Grumpy Old Buckeye: Ohio State vs. Wisconsin II

You’re supposed to save your best for last, but Ohio State saved its worst game of the season for the Big Ten Championship Game, falling behind 21-7 in the first half before rallying with 27 consecutive points in the second half. There was a lot to be grumpy about, but I’m just going to hit the highlights (lowlights?) because otherwise you’d be reading this column for several days. Let’s get to the stuff that would have had a much richer version of me shooting my television.

Big Play to Open the Game

The Buckeyes wasted no time showing they weren’t ready for Wisconsin’s best shot. Wisconsin opened the game with a 27-yard completion on the first play and it set the tone for the Badger offense and the Buckeye defense. Ohio State seemed to struggle to recover, looking unsure, missing tackles, and generally appearing unsettled and on their heels.

Taylor’s Response

After being held in check the first two times he faced Ohio State, Jonathan Taylor came into this game wanting to make a statement and did that early. He had a 44-yard touchdown run to open the scoring, further giving Wisconsin life and belief. Jeff Okudah was the last guy to have a shot at him but made an awful attempt to bring down the runner and just like that Taylor practically ran for more yards in one play than he did in Columbus during the first meeting.

Your Weekly Reminder that Chrisman is Broken

Tired: Drue Chrisman booting his punts into the end zone.

Wired: Drue Chrisman going back to doing what he used to do. He hasn’t done that much since before the first Wisconsin game.

I’ve been riding this particular gripe train ever since the first Wisconsin game, but once again Chrisman had an opportunity to pin back an opponent and booted a punt into the end zone. However, he might have gotten his groove back with a perfect pass on a fake punt (even if the Buckeyes didn’t finish the drive). Late in the game he actually did force a fair catch inside the 20, so let’s hope he’s finally back.

The Whiff

Jashon Cornell missed what looked like a sure sack on third-and-9 on second Wisconsin scoring drive, getting his hands on Jack Coan deep in the backfield, but he lost his grip and allowed a long scramble for a first down. Just a couple of plays later, Coan walked into the end zone with no trouble on a zone read keeper that fooled everyone in a white jersey. Making that sack probably saves the Buckeyes a touchdown.

Trying To Do Too Much Can Be Costly

Ohio State had a third down play in the red zone and Wisconsin got pressure that forced Justin Fields to run. But once he was wrapped up, he tried to fight through the entire Badger defense and lost the ball. That cost Ohio State points as Fields could simply have gone down and taken the field goal. By trying to make what was just about an impossible play — even if he had two healthy knees — it cost the Buckeyes and helped the Badgers.

Awful Response

Ohio State finally scored a touchdown to get back into the game and Wisconsin seemed OK with taking their touchdown lead to the half. But then the Buckeyes gave up a 45-yard rush by Taylor on a simple run play right before the half that led to a third Wisconsin touchdown. The Badgers weren’t even trying to score necessarily. But when Ohio State gave up the big play, the Badgers got aggressive, picked on backup cornerback Cameron Brown and then made it 21-7 just before the break. It was the most demoralizing 32-second sequence of the entire season. If the Buckeyes had simply made a tackle for an average three to five yards on that run, they’d have gone to the half down just seven points.

Failing to Take Full Advantage

Ohio State scored a touchdown to start the third quarter and then got a huge sack of Coan on third down on the ensuing drive. Things looked even better when Wisconsin’s punter dropped the snap and set up the Buckeyes in the red zone. But then the Buckeyes went with a gadget play on first down, a run, and then should have at least converted for a first down — if not a touchdown — when Fields misfired to a wide open tight end in the flat with a lot of green in front of him. Instead of seven points, Ohio State settled for three and that was a big win for the Badgers.

Wint’s Dumb Penalty; Arnette’s Dumb Penalty

The Buckeyes handed Wisconsin 30 yards for free on the same drive in the form of a couple of unsportsmanlike conduct penalties. Jahsen Wint’s came on the kickoff after Ohio State had climbed back into the game and Damon Arnette’s was a few plays later. The defense eventually got a stop and the Badgers missed a field goal on the drive, but that was not a good time for some discipline issues, whether the calls were soft or not.

Suplex is for Wrestling Only

K.J. Hill got picked up and slammed down on an overhead suplex move that would have made Hulk Hogan proud. That is supposed to be illegal and could have ended Hill’s season. Thankfully, he was OK and set the school record for career receptions and then later scored a go-ahead touchdown on a play where Garrett Wilson got away with not being set at the snap. I’ll take the no-call on Wilson since there was no call on the Hill suplex.

Those are the main things. There were a few other items that kind of cropped up from time to time, such as some calls not made or poor tackling at times, and a few play calls were curious, but those are more general and less specific. In the end, Fields remembered he was Fields (one leg or not), the Buckeyes fed J.K. Dobbins, and the defense showed up and made plays to get off the field. The second half was much less aggravating than the first, and once Ohio State got momentum, the Buckeyes pretty much seemed normal, despite Fields’ limitations.

That’s it for the Big Ten season. We’ll find out the next opponent and location today and until then, get some rest and stay hydrated.



8 Responses

  1. On Wisconsin’s opening drive Tyreke Smith was held right in front of the ref who ignorantly kept his flag safe and secure in his pants. Had Smith NOT been held he probably would have decapitated Coan.

    It’s gone beyond getting old watching each successive team allowed to hold against the Buckeyes defensive front. Guarantee it’s discussed before the game in the refs meeting and with the Big 10 officials to do all they can to level the field. Just like against the Varmints, I’m going back to count the blatant holds. Against TTUN there was 5 they “could” have called against the Buckeyes, and 14 they could have called against the northern trailer trash.

    Said it many, many times. Big 10 refs are far and away THE worst excuses for officiating ever in CFB, and the League Administration criminal in allowing the crap to continue.

    1. Correction. Smith was blatantly held 2 times in the first 5 plays of the game. Both times he had a bead on Coan and would likely have crushed him.

      It’s beyond time that Conference Administration gets flushed, and they bring in refs with a clue.

  2. Can’t believe you called out Cornell for “the whiff”. He was initially held on that play, broke thru the holding, then was shoved in the back. That’s why he missed the tackle.

    He was also held on Taylor’s 44 yd run – he would have made that tackle for little gain. Cornell played awesome!.

    1. Joe dead on with your comments. WTF have we been unable to get any holding calls all year long? Kinda limits the impact of a hellacious pass rush if their O lines are allowed to clothsline, dosey doe and Tennessee waltz Chase and company

  3. Pass protection. If the OL can’t get it together to protect their QB when they know his mobility is hampered by a knee injury, then they never will. They need to pass block like their season depends on it, because it does.

    The lack of defensive pass rush has a rippling effect on our entire defense. It leads to our LBs drifting out of the passing lanes and our DBs chasing receivers all over the field. Everyone is on their heels. It’s hard to watch.

  4. These unsportsmanlike conduct penalties HAVE TO STOP. 30 free yards given up on one drive. Not acceptable. This is not a matter of too much effort. It is a loss of mental control. Coaches need to do more than talk about it. Players who commit these dumb penalties should have to sit for some meaningful period of time. Otherwise, the pattern will continue in the CFP and that spells disaster.

  5. Michael- in addition, defense looked inebriated the first half. And Justin Fields was off, receivers were making circus catches to keep things going.

    1. You are right about the circus catches but Justin Fields was throwing off his back foot the entire game because of his heavy knee brace and damaged knee. Not being able to step into his throws caused most all of his balls to be high. I think it was amazing that he threw as well as he did with one leg. Lets just hope that his knee is much better by 12/28. If he could just regain 50% of his normal mobility, it would make beating Clemson much more likely. And also, if our coaches can make needed adjustments sooner.
      That being said, we ran through a very tough and highly motivated gauntlet the last three games and still won every game by double digits.

Comments are closed.