Football Hayes & Cannon

The Grumpy Old Buckeye: Ohio State vs. Penn State

It was a game that was much closer than it should have been, so it was the perfect postgame for me to walk out on my lawn in my bathrobe and slippers and start shaking my fist at passersby. Ohio State controlled the game against Penn State except when the Buckeyes decided to roll the ball on the ground for fun or call plays everyone knew was coming but they tried them anyway. It was a head-scratching game with uncharacteristic turnovers and play calling but in the end, Ohio State won by two scores in a series that’s been razor thin in terms of victory margin in recent years.

Let’s see what really got my blood boiling in a 28-17 win over Penn State.

Haubeil’s Opening Kickoff

It didn’t take long to get my dander up. Blake Haubeil has — either by design or failure to execute — left a lot of kickoffs short this year. His opening kickoff was particularly short, which set up Penn State in excellent field position to start the game. The Nittany Lions started at their 40. The Buckeyes eventually stopped the drive but then had to go more than 90 yards as a result. It’s nice that they could do it, but a better kickoff would have reduced the level of difficulty.

The Fields Fumble

Ohio State was about to take a two-touchdown lead in the first quarter when Justin Fields lost the football going into the end zone. It wasn’t the first time this season Fields has lost the ball while going in, but this time he lost it before the goal line and it was a turnover instead of a score. It also wrecked a great defensive stand that got the offense the ball in Penn State territory. The stop gave life to Penn State, which then moved the ball down the field on the OSU defense before stalling and punting in plus territory to flip the field.

Munford’s Very Bad Drive

Tackle Thayer Munford cost his team dearly early in the second quarter and stopped a promising drive. A big run by J.K. Dobbins earned a first down but Munford was whistled for what looked to be a pretty weak holding call. Honestly I’m more angry with the call considering what Chase Young had to put up with all day. But Munford then got beat to allow a sack on the next play. When you stack those two errors (OK, an error and a borderline malpractice suit against the officials) with him being blown up twice on run plays for negative yardage earlier in the half, it was not the best we’ve seen from Munford in 2019.

Drue Chrisman: Still Broken?

Wisconsin obviously needs to start paying rent to live in Drue Chrisman’s head. The previously brilliant punter has been average to poor ever since seeing his boot blocked in the third quarter of that game. His first opportunity to pin Penn State deep in its own territory sailed into the end zone. Downing the ball inside the 20, previously a specialty of Chrisman, has been almost non-existent since the Wisconsin block. However, maybe there were signs of him coming out of that, as he downed his next two punts inside the 20 and finished with a 43-yard average. Let the turnaround begin.

Teague’s Trials and Tribulations

Master Teague got a series in the second quarter and it went poorly. On first down, he carried wide and appeared to stumble on the turf and lost yardage. Before the next snap, Teague committed a false start while lined up wide and that was it for his first half. Teague has been a great player for the Buckeyes this season and maybe he was a bit too amped up in such a big game. He did later have a nice run for a first down when Ohio State was trying to run out the clock.

Final Drive of the First Half

Ohio State botched a chance for points late in the first half with numerous mistakes in plus territory on the final drive of the second quarter. Fields did well to avoid the pass rush but then floated his pass for Chris Olave, who failed to make a catch he normally makes — despite the defender hitting him just before the ball arrived on an uncalled pass interference that was caused by the floating pass. Branden Bowen then got flagged for an illegal formation. Fields then tried an interior scramble to avoid the pass rush rather than getting outside where acres of open space awaited. To make matters worse, he had a wide open receiver on a crossing route that he didn’t see just before he tried scrambling. With the Buckeyes getting the first possession of the second half, Ryan Day opted not to try a Hail Mary play on third and extremely long. I mean…you’ve got Olave, Ben Victor, and Garrett Wilson.

Terrible Tackling Returns

Ohio State’s defense tackled poorly on the first Penn State drive of the third quarter. Malik Harrison could have stopped Journey Brown for a loss but instead gave up a chunk run. Then Brown shrugged off multiple Buckeyes to score a touchdown to cap the drive. It’s not the kind of tackling we’re accustomed to from Ohio State’s defenders, especially fresh out of the locker room. And then things got worse.

Dobbins’ Drop

On the first play after the Nittany Lions’ touchdown, the Buckeyes called the same exact running play to the left they had called all day and it finally cost them. Dobbins allowed a weak strip while trying to hunt for a hole to run into and cutting back to his right. His fumble allowed the Nitts to score just a couple of plays later and got Penn State back into the game, turning a game that was about to get out of hand into something that was very much still in hand.

The Fields Fumble II

Fields lost his second fumble of the day with the score tightening, only this time his knee certainly appeared to be down before the ball came out. The officiating crew didn’t see it that way even when the video showed his knee on the ground with the ball still in his hand. This was the second review that seemed clear and obvious but didn’t get overturned, with the first being the initial Penn State touchdown. Just throw replay out if you’re not going to use it to overturn obvious calls. Penn State cashed in with a field goal to make it 17 unanswered points, of which 10 were handed over free of charge.

Law of Averages is a Jerk

Penn State had its second muffed snap deep in its own territory and once again the Nitts got the favorable bounce of the oblong ball. Penn State was five-for-five at that point in fortunate bounces, getting on three Ohio State fumbles and two of its own muffed snaps. This one would have almost certainly given Ohio State seven points as Chase Young may have gotten that in the end zone or at worst on the 1-yard line. The Nitts then got on a Will Levis fumble that Young forced later to go six-for-six on balls on the ground. Law of Averages, you are a jerk, but feel free to make it up to us next Saturday or in Indianapolis in two weeks.

Playing Scared?

Ohio State’s play calling was perplexing almost all day. Granted, the OSU pass protection could have been better, but after two straight weeks of watching the Nittany Lions get carved up through the air, it was weird not to see more from the passing game. The rain didn’t really set in until the third quarter. When Ohio State decided to pass, it was usually in a more obvious down and distance than you’d like. The Buckeyes tried a lot more straight quarterback runs than we’ve seen previously and there was really nothing unexpected. If I can predict the next play, I would expect a college defensive coordinator to be able to do it. I’d rather think Ryan Day and company were refusing to show stuff to Michigan than playing afraid. Personally I think that cautious coaching rubs off on the players. They’re wild stallions who are used to running free. Let them run.


That’s what got my blood pressure up on Saturday. In the end, it probably didn’t go up as high as the last few years’ worth of Penn State games. It was good to see Ohio State get a four-quarter test and face more athletic competition. Hopefully it will be a springboard to bigger things.

It’s hard to believe but there is only one more of these for me to write in the 2019 regular season as Ohio State and That Team Up North renew the greatest rivalry in sports next Saturday.

17 Responses

  1. FWIW, OSU is 14-1 against Scum in the last 15 games. Maybe it isn’t THE GAME any more.

  2. So hard to resist adding to the negative commentary. All season long I have appreciated the real pace of the OSU offennse. Enough of Urban Meyers smoke and mirrors covering up of an indecisive, poorly coordinated offensive signal calling. Yesterday all of a sudden the same terrible picture of watching faces on the field waiting for the plays to come in. Constantly failing to sieze the advantage when plays succeeded by then giving the Penn State defense all day to set up for the next play. If I am Jim Harbaugh I am already telling my guys just stack 8 in the box on every first down because Ohio State is fixated on running Dobbins every first down, no matter the result.
    The 4th and five play, give me a break! Day is really too good for the nonsense of the play calling of this his first real challenging game.
    Ohio State’s offense this year has become habituialy excellent and I can see the pitfalls of coaching to simply blowout everyone. So I can see some of what Day was avoiding. But a coach must never stop leveraging his skill advantage when he has it. Pace is what makes Ohio State the great team that it is. Ohio State’s great skill at receivers can only be neutralized when the Buckeye coaching staff fails to use them. Go Bucks, Be relentless against Michigan!

    1. FWIW, looked to me like they expected the rain earlier than it happened. Typical cold/rain day game plan to me.

  3. Gosh dang it Michael, I must be turning into a Grumpy Old Buckeye, because I’m with you on everything you wrote – and then some! We won, obviously, but the win feels empty in a way. A sure cure for this would be a solid thumping of that team up north next weekend. Go Bucks! Beat Xichigan!

  4. The Grumpy Old Buckeye is the FIRST Article I read when I come to the O-ZONE! I love it!

  5. I think we were coaching scared not so much playing scared. The play calling I just did not understand and why not any play action passes on first down ?

    I did not understand going for it on 4th and 5 at end of the game. Kick a field goal or punt the ball.

    I like Fields and he is young and I think he will play much better next year, but he has to protect the ball better this year.

  6. Bad playing on offense and defense, coupled with three turnovers, usually leads to a loss. The fact that OSU won by double digits is impressive. Clean up even half of the stuff that went wrong, and we win by 3 TDs. Let’s hope this is a learning opportunity for both the players and coaches, and we move forward. Go Bucks!

  7. Yes it may have been a vanilla game plan, but how would you feel if it had been a wide open game and the Bucks lost. We won for goodness sake. Let’s just win next week and on to Indy.

  8. I thought the offensive game plan STUNK. What separates a really good HC from a truly great HC? His heart. In a competitive sport you have to have that nasty killer instinct and the devil be damned.

    What is Justin Fields missing at this point? The toughness of JT Barrett and the accuracy of Haskins. He runs with all the conviction of Braxton Miller……without the speed, and all the ball security of a Sophomore year Eddie George. He’s a case of what Coach Meyer referred to as a, “product of those around him.” To date he’s yet to show a willingness to simply take over games. Weak hands, lack of intensity, and no concept of keeping play timing on schedule. A Heisman candidate? Yeah, me too.

    1. Give me a break! Couldn’t disagree with all of that nonsense more.

      1. I couldn’t give a crap less what you think………….or the fact that you can’t think for yourself.

    2. A part of me wonders if this gameplan wasn’t just to feed Xichigan and Hairball meaningless video in their preparations for The Game. While I agree with you that the gameplan and playcalling sucked, I’ve never had reason to doubt Ryan Day’s HEART. He’s always exhibited heart in spades whether it be during a sideline interview, postgame interview, on the call in shows or when getting fans amped for the game. Maybe I’m incorrectly equating emotion with heart. But something tells me this game plan was installed as much to make Xichigan forget about the Mesh as it was to beat Penn State.

      1. Ryan Day coached scared. He didn’t say it exactly like that in his post game comments, but that’s actually what he was saying.

        People get mad at me here because I’m not afraid to take off my otherwise very scarlet and gray glasses and say what I believe I watched. Nobody has to agree, or disagree, they’re just my personal observations. Day simply confirmed them. Not in my words but his own.

        One thing I’ll always believe. If you’re playing to “not lose,” you’re not playing to win. If you’re playing safe to keep guys from getting hurt, you can almost be sure that someone is going to get hurt. Ohio State is fortunate enough to bring in some of the best of the best athletes and football players from around the Country. Let them do their thing without restraints on the pretext of protecting them. There’s a sound reasoning. When you hold them back you’re exposing them to the dangers of out manned opponents being able to get in shots they otherwise wouldn’t be able to get in because your players aren’t properly stretched and warmed up. Players are more likely to get hurt because they aren’t warmed, and they’re attention is dulled on execution and technique, rather than cutting loose and doing what they’re trained to do.

    3. I think we all need to remember that this is Field’s first year as a starterr and Day’s 1st year as a coach and OSU is breaking in 4 new OL. This was the first game that OSU was pressed half way through the 3rd quarter and the first game OSU fans contemplated the thought of a possible barn burner or……….. This was a grow up game for the O, OL, Fields and Day. W/o the turnovers, OSU scores at least 35 and PSU maybe 10. Field’s legs and about 6 awesome throws won this game. The question is how will OSU respond next week, specifically Day and Fields.

  9. The reality is that partially due to Field’s fumble in the endzone, OSU dominated statistically, but not on the score board. In many ways it was a grow up games for both sides of the ball, as well as Fields and Day.

    1. True statement, Kurt. While the national media completely misses on it (suckling as it is on their SEC narrative) this just might be what brings this team to full focus like Va Tech did in ’14.

  10. Ryan Day specifically said that he wasn’t saving anything for TTUN. You didn’t hear the post-game interview. He essentially admitted to calling the game scared at points.
    A friend of mine pointed out to me before this game that the Buckeyes had the chance to tie a 116-year-old NCAA record – 11 games winning by 24 points or more set by 1903 TTUN. This would set up beautifully to rub TTUN’s noses in it by winning by 24 or more next week. But the gaffes wrecked that.
    You didn’t mention the pass play call on 4th and 5, Dobby whiffing on the blitz pickup, and Fields not throwing it away in the face of a freight train that nearly got him hurt and out of the rest of the season.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *