LOS ANGELES — How do you help a freshman quarterback making his first career start on the road, leading a 6-1 team ranked No. 2 in the country?
By making his life easy. By not making mistakes. By playing fundamentally sound football in all three phases.
Ohio State spent the entire week saying it would do exactly that for true freshman quarterback Luke Fahey. With Julian Sayin unavailable, the Buckeyes knew they would need everyone to step up around their first-time starting quarterback. Ryan Day said it. His players echoed it. The message was clear: Fahey would have the support of the entire team.
Then Saturday happened.
For 60 minutes at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, Ohio State did just about everything it could to make Fahey’s first start more difficult. Drops, penalties, missed tackles, explosive plays allowed, special teams miscues and missed opportunities in the red zone turned what should have been a collective effort into a frustrating night for the Buckeyes.
The result was a 30-18 loss to USC on Halloween, one that had little to do with any one player and everything to do with a team that failed to deliver on the promise it made all week.
Fahey was not perfect. Making his first career start against a Big Ten opponent on the road was always going to come with a learning curve, and there were moments when the freshman could have been better. He completed 21 of 38 passes for 260 yards and a touchdown without throwing an interception, but Ohio State struggled to turn its offensive opportunities into points.
The Buckeyes totaled 464 yards, including 204 on the ground. Backs Bo Jackson and Isaiah West combined for 193 rushing yards on 34 carries, while Jeremiah Smith caught 10 passes for 83 yards and a touchdown. Connor Hawkins made all four of his field-goal attempts.
There were individual performances to build on. There just weren’t enough of them to make up for everything else that went wrong.
“It’s truly frustrating… just too many penalties,” Day said after the game. “We found ourselves down in those redzone situations and we just weren’t able to execute very well, play clean, and then the penalties were not good.”
That lack of execution showed up early and often. Ohio State’s first four drives reached USC territory, but the Buckeyes repeatedly settled for field goals instead of touchdowns. A goal-line opportunity before halftime was particularly costly. Fahey appeared to get into the end zone on a quarterback sneak, but replay showed he was short. Ohio State then failed to punch the ball in, settling for another Hawkins field goal.
It was the kind of opportunity a team cannot afford to waste when it is trying to make life easier for a young quarterback.
The passing game also failed to provide the consistent support Fahey needed. There were drops, including opportunities that could have created significant gains, and the offensive line had trouble keeping USC’s pass rush away from the freshman. Fahey was sacked twice and faced pressure throughout the night.
Mason Williams said he thought Fahey handled the moment as well as the team could have expected, but he also recognized that the responsibility did not belong to the quarterback alone.
“I don’t think we could have expected anything better from Luke today,” Williams said. “He went out there, and he battled his butt off.”
Williams said the rest of the team needed to do its part when a freshman was put in that position.
“When you get a freshman quarterback in a big game like that, when you got what you got out of him today, we got to be able to do our jobs,” Williams said. “Everyone on the field strives to make his job a little easier.”
That was the expectation Ohio State had set for itself all week. It was also the expectation it failed to meet.
The problems were not limited to the offense. Ohio State’s defense made the freshman’s job harder before he had much of a chance to settle into the game.
On USC’s second play from scrimmage, quarterback Jayden Maiava found Trent Mosley on a screen pass, and the receiver took it 69 yards for a touchdown. It was an immediate reminder of the kind of explosive plays Ohio State had largely avoided giving up throughout the season.
The Trojans found another opportunity to flip the field on special teams. A 44-yard punt return by Mosley, followed by a 15-yard penalty on Beau Atkinson, gave USC possession at the Ohio State 32-yard line. Four plays later, Waymond Jordan scored from nine yards out.
Ohio State’s defense did force a turnover in the first half, with Earl Little Jr. forcing and recovering a fumble, but the Buckeyes could not consistently get USC off the field or keep the Trojans from creating big plays.
The most damaging came after halftime. Isaiah West fumbled on a reception to open the second half, giving USC another short field. Two plays later, Maiava connected with Mark Bowman, who turned the catch into a 70-yard gain. King Miller scored from one yard out shortly afterward, extending USC’s lead to 27-9.
The Buckeyes recorded nine tackles for loss, but those plays were overshadowed by the explosive gains and missed tackles that allowed USC to control the game. The Trojans finished with 338 total yards, 126 fewer than Ohio State, but made their opportunities count.
Ohio State also played without freshman defensive back Jay Timmons, who aggravated an injury during the Indiana game. Day said Timmons had made progress during the week but was not ready to return. His absence was felt, particularly in a game in which USC repeatedly found ways to get its playmakers into space.
Day acknowledged the defense had opportunities to make plays but did not finish them. The Buckeyes needed to tackle better, limit the explosive gains and give their offense a chance to stay in the game. They did not do enough of any of those things.
Special teams and penalties added to the frustration. Ohio State was flagged 11 times for 71 yards, repeatedly putting itself in difficult situations. The Buckeyes had mistakes on punts and failed to create a meaningful advantage in the return game. None of those errors happened in isolation. Together, they became another part of a performance that never looked like the clean, complementary football Ohio State had spent the week promising.
To Fahey’s credit, he continued to compete. The freshman led a 13-play, 80-yard touchdown drive late in the fourth quarter, connecting with Smith for a one-yard score with 2:12 remaining. The touchdown gave Smith his 40th career receiving score, breaking the Big Ten record previously held by Braylon Edwards.
But by then, Ohio State was trailing by 15. The two-point conversion failed, and the Buckeyes’ onside kick attempt was recovered by USC. The Trojans added a field goal to make it 30-18, and Fahey’s final pass on fourth-and-10 fell incomplete with 36 seconds remaining.
There was no dramatic comeback, no late opportunity to turn the night around. Just the final seconds of a game in which Ohio State had spent far too much time making its own job harder.
The Buckeyes had talked all week about what it would take to support Fahey. They needed to run the ball, protect him, make catches, tackle, avoid penalties and play complementary football. Jackson and West ran hard. Smith produced. Hawkins made every field goal. But the team as a whole never put together the kind of performance that could carry a first-time starting quarterback through a difficult road game.
Day did not shy away from that reality afterward.
“For Luke [Fahey], he competed. It wasn’t perfect, but we had some drops and we weren’t able to help him out there,” Day said. “He competed his tail off in there. We’ll look at the film and recognize things that we got to improve on in terms of what we can do to put him in a better situation.”
He later put it even more plainly.
“At the end of the day, as a team we weren’t able to play well enough to support a young freshman quarterback who was in his first start on the road like this,” Day said.
That is the part Ohio State cannot afford to overlook as it moves forward. Fahey will have to learn from his first start, and he will need to improve. But the Buckeyes cannot ask a freshman quarterback to be perfect while the players around him make the game harder at every turn.
If Fahey is going to continue leading the offense, the message from this week needs to become more than something Ohio State says. The Buckeyes spent their bye week and another six days promising to step up for their freshman quarterback. Against USC, they spent 60 minutes showing how much work they still have to do.
Photo courtesy of Ohio State Dept. of Athletics.


